Mock Turtle Soup

Celebrate Charleston Food and Wine: Enjoy Mock Turtle Soup

The above is an excerpt from the Charleston Courier on March 22, 1865, recounting the Freedmen’s Jubilee Parade, which featured a black man on a float with a woman and two children whom he was pretending to auction off “for good Confederate money”. He played his part with vigor and conviction, causing much mirth and merriment in the crowd of black faces.
The Charleston Food and Wine Festival is in full swing this weekend and I noticed that the Grand Opening Event featured a theme of recipes from Charleston Receipts, the first Junior League cookbook. In print since 1952, it is the Bible of Charleston cookery. The Post and Courier writer noted in Wednesday’s Food Section that the Grand Opening menu wasn’t announced. She then proceeds to speculate on the soup choice. Deeming She Crab Soup to mundane, she speculates on a number of choices including a fish stew, an okra gumbo, or–mock turtle soup.
I have always been a fan of turtle soup. My parents would often visit the Doc and Nananne in New Orleans (my great Aunt and Uncle) and they would return with tales of delicious turtle soup. They brought back two cans of turtle soup for me to try. The rich, dark stew with a splash of dry sherry was absolute heaven to my 8-year-old palate I have never forgotten it. And so, since I could not attend the Grand Opening, I decided to celebrate Food and Wine by recreating that taste of my childhood.

Mock Turtle Soup
But first, a little history of turtle soup. For many years turtle soup was considered the finest of fine dining. In the early 20th century, the Villa Marguerita, Charleston’s finest hotel of the time, had a $20 bowl of turtle soup on the menu. Turtle meat was considered a delicacy, and exotic because the meat comes from 5 different places on the turtle, all with different tastes. A large snapping turtle is said to contain seven distinct types of meat, each reminiscent of pork, chicken, beef, shrimp, veal, fish, or goat. Locally, this dish of English extraction did not survive in Charleston households into the twentieth century. Although Charlestonians continued to hire black cooks, few were trained in making Eurocentric foods, and so the foodways that have survived and that we consider Lowcountry style generally have their roots in Africa, but not turtle soup.
For many years sea turtles were the meat of choice, so the real thing was out of the question. Where to find turtle meat today? Of course, cooters are ubiquitous, but I live in an apartment, and dressing them would be an issue. I’m not sure that I am prepared to grab the head, chop it off and hang it upside down to the drain. The high cost of sea turtle meat led to the creation of Mock Turtle Soup. Using the same rich broth and a variety of meats in the broth, Mock Turtle Soup imitates not just the flavor but the texture and look of the real thing. As an aside, I used chicken livers snipped into small pieces, and that dark flavor is absolutely correct, but you might choose to use dark chicken meat, even surimi (artificial crab), or mild fish filets for this.
Next, I had to find the recipe, so first I went to Charleston Receipts. Mrs. Alston’s version found there bears little resemblance to the soup of my childhood. Next, I searched the internet and pulled out different recipes with the ingredients that I remember as crucial to the thick, brown heady broth of distant memory. My creation is exactly as I remember it, and for that reason, I share it with you. Doubtless, turtle soup fans will enjoy this tasty recreation! Bon Appetit!
Mock Turtle Soup My Recipe Alfred Ray

  1. To one and one-half quarts of water add one pound raw lean ground beef and one half pound raw chicken livers sliced small, three bay leaves, and 1 teaspoon salt.
    Set to boil.
  2. Take one-half stick of butter heated with flour, and brown to make a rue for thickening. Set aside.
  3. Dice both fine and medium:
    One yellow onion
    One red bell pepper
    Two stalks of celery.
    Put these in two tablespoons of butter on medium-high for five minutes, and then high until vegetables are cooked with a char. Add this to the broth. Deglaze the pan with dry sherry, scrape bits and throw all into the pot along with
    One can beef bouillon
    one cup of tomato ketchup
    One large can of crushed tomatoes
    Stir this all together and bring it to a boil. Add to this
    1 teaspoon each of allspice and thyme,3 tablespoons Worcestershire Sauce
    Juice ½ lemon.
    4 eggs in the shell
    Simmer all together for at least 45 minutes, 1 1/2 hours is better. Remove hard-boiled eggs and macerate. Add back to thicken the soup. Add rue (step 2) to thicken to a stew consistency.
    To serve, plate soup piping hot and garnish with parsley and dry sherry.

Charleston Old Walled City Tours offers public and private walking tours and driving tours of historic Charleston SC and the surrounding countryside. For information go to
Charleston Old Walled City Tours offers themed tours of Historic Charleston including the Old Walled City Tour, the Home and Garden Tour, the Slavery and Freedom Tour, and the Charleston Ghost Walk. Go to www.walledcitytours.come to learn more!



Leave a Comment

Social Media

Most Popular

Get The Latest Updates

Subscribe To Our Weekly Newsletter

No spam, notifications only about new products, updates.
Scroll to Top